The Battle of the Bottle {When Your Breastfed Baby Puts Up a Fight}

Everyone talks about how hard breastfeeding is, but no one ever informs you of the frustrating battle when your breastfed baby refuses a bottle.

My first child was breastfed for 6 months and would take milk from any “vessel,” as I used to boast to our friends and family. Surely, the second would do the same, right?

Ha. Negative.

I climbed down from the attic and confidently unpacked the Dr. Browns and Playtex bottles from their cardboard homes. Freshly washed & sterilized, the troops were ready for their second deployment. The liquid gold poured in easy. We were ready.

Well, we thought we were ready. After the first comical hour long bottle-feeding battle ended in hysterics (NOT the funny kind), I thought surely it was because I was trying to give her the bottle. I justified her reasoning: If I’d like a glass of fine wine, I’d be upset if it came to me in a beer stein.

So, I called in the reinforcements *ahem the next victim* … my husband.

Leave the room, he said. It’ll be fine, he said. Well I left the room, the house, the cul-de-sac. Honestly, I felt like fleeing the country after the 100th undrunk drop. She would just scream and flail and give you that look that made you want to wave the white flag of surrender.

I knew that in a matter of a few weeks I had to go to back work and that, well, it was kind of my duty to make sure I kept the kid alive. I kicked it into high gear and decided to make the rounds with the allies. We would try every type of bottle we owned or could borrow until we would find THE ONE!

1. Hospital liquid formula bottle nipple

If we used these little disposables to supplement during the first few days of her life, then it should be the obvious choice right? Wrong. These were nothing like the breast and were apparently offensive when presented as an option.

2. Playtex Nurser

My old faithful bottles with drop-ins to keep air out and keep mom’s cleaning to a minimum. My mom used these back in the gap. I used them with my first daughter, but #2 wanted nothing to do with these except to play with the “bag” (and scream).

3. Playtex Vent Aire

More affectionately known as the sister bottle of the Playtex Nurser — that this sister rejected as well. Because this bottle has an angled neck, we even tried holding it in a way that mimicked being held and breastfed. Didn’t work.

4. Dr. Browns

Mama called the doctor and the doctor said “ Your baby wants the breast instead.” So many parts made the cleanup undesirable as well.

5. Munchkin Latch

It’s the bottle Target gives you when you create a baby registry. All things from Target must possess some magical powers, right?! Even it failed us.

6. Old school glass bottle

Lets just say the risk was not worth the reward. Disclaimer: No mothers, fathers, grandmothers, aunties, or babies were harmed in the trial of this bottle.

7. Medela

My pump was Medela. So, breast milk + pump brand bottle = match made in heaven, right? This one was a tad closer but too small of a nipple. She was not fooled. 

8. Lasinoh mOmma

This bottle is shaped like a sphere. Boobs are spheres. The logic is there, right? Nice try, BUT she would accept it near her lips so #mOmmawin there.

We were 0 for 8 with no clear victor. So, like any desperate and confused parents would do, we proceeded to order every bottle that the web said was “breast” to try.

9. Bare

This bottle not only comes with a minimal name but also very unique and unconventional instructions. She couldn’t “bare” drinking from it.

10. Adiri Nxgen Nurser

Having the softest nipple that proved acceptable for at least a few suckles, the Adiri bottle was a strong contender.

11. Comotomo

A highly recommended option, this bottle is actually squeezable and proved to be more of a toy than a bottle for my babe. Complete flip side of the old-fashioned glass bottles.

12. Mimijumi

The runner up! I’m not sure if it was the flesh color or smooth texture of the nipple, but something about this bottle was intriguing to my little one. It came with a hefty price but was definitely the “gateway” to bottle drinking success.

We ended up trying 12 different bottles before landing on 1 victorious Holy Grail of bottles that sufficed for my picky eater.

 13. Minbie 

Do you ever notice when Facebook ads start to relate to your every need? Creepy technology turned out to be very useful in this case. Literally the strangest shaped nipple I have seen to date, but she took it in all its skinny, angled nipple glory!

Granted, the feeding process still took about an hour per bottle, but with a very patient milk maid wielding the Minbie, I felt victorious for finally hunting down an option that “worked” for us.

The moral of the story is: some breastfed babies just refuse a bottle. And it sucks (pun intended). My only advice to other mothers crawling through these trenches is to open up a “bottle” of your favorite beverage too and keep battling!

Christy Loustalot
Christy is a fun-loving wife and mother of two little ladies Amelia (7) and Gwendolyn (3) currently residing in Broussard. She met her husband, Thomas, through Greek life in college at the University of Louisiana at Lafayette and the rest, as they say, is history. Christy is the Lead Designer at Confetti Momma. She is obsessed with her job and is currently working on developing the perfect balance between work and home life. Being a little bit corny and a LOT cheesy, she lives for the laugh and appreciates a good pun. Making people smile gives her the warm fuzzies. Christy loves baking with her daughters, Gilmore Girls, game nights with friends, and all things frozen (as in ice cream and snowballs- although Anna and Elsa are her home girls). Oh! And coffee … lets not forget coffee!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here