Roll Out the Fun with a King Cake Taste-Off!

It’s that vibrant time of the year again – Mardi Gras season! And what better way to celebrate the season than with a King Cake Taste-Off? After our own deliciously successful 2nd annual King Cake Taste-Off, we’re here to share how you can bring this joyous occasion to your home. It’s time to indulge in the best of Lafayette’s King Cakes!

Get the Party Started – Everyone’s a Judge!

You can start by sending out playful invitations to your friends and this can be as simple as a group text. Emphasize the mission: each guest should bring a unique King Cake to the party. Picture this: a table that’s just bursting with life and Mardi Gras spirit, decked out with over 11 King Cakes from Lafayette’s crème de la crème bakers. Each one’s like a little party in itself, promising you a whole new world of flavors to dive into. It’s not just a feast for your taste buds; it’s a feast for your eyes too!

The King Cake Parade – A Flavor for Every Palate

Our party was a whirlwind of surprises! From the unique Cookie Dough filling from Rouses to the yummy Cookie Butter from Mrs. B’s Sweets and Treats, each cake brought its own personality. And let’s not forget the classic Cream Cheese delight from Crystal Weddings! The variety is key here – encourage your guests to bring something unexpected.

Setting Up Your Taste-Off

  1. Create a Tasting Station: Arrange all the cakes on a large table. Be sure to provide plates, forks, napkins, and scorecards for guests to rate each cake. Label the cakes with numbers and the corresponding plates to keep track of which cake is which.
  2. Palette Cleansers and Beverages: Don’t forget to have coffee, tea, or water on hand to cleanse the palate between tastings. And for an extra festive touch, set up a daiquiri station or a mimosa bar. A variety of juices, fresh fruits, and sparkling wine will be perfect for complementing the King Cake experience.
  3. Judging Criteria and Scorecard: Consider taste, filling, texture, appearance, creativity, and that ‘wow’ factor, just like we did. Encourage guests to be as descriptive as possible on their scorecards. This not only makes the judging more fun but also helps in deciding the winner with more specifics. To keep the judging fair and fun, use a structured scorecard. Here’s the link to our scorecard that made things pretty simple and fair for everyone.
  4. Fun Awards: Alongside the traditional categories, consider playful awards like “Most Surprising Flavor” or “Most Likely to Eat for Breakfast”. This encourages guests to think outside the box and adds an extra layer of fun to the taste-off.

Our Top Picks – Could They Be Yours Too?

1. 🥇 Eat Fuel Fleurish Boudin King Cake: This was the star! Its unique taste left us craving for more – not a crumb was left!
2.🥈 Crystal Weddings Cream Cheese King Cake**: A classic that never disappoints. Its creamy goodness is a testament to why Crystal Weddings is a top bakery.
3. 🥉 Rouses Cookies and Cream Queen’s Cake: This one will surprise you, showing that even grocery stores can bring their A-game to King Cake season.

Share the Love – Support Local Bakers

This is more than just a fun gathering; it’s a chance to celebrate and support our local bakers who bring us these incredible flavors and Mardi Gras magic. Check out our king cake guide for more Lafayette favorites – your new go-to might just be waiting for you to discover it!

Hosting Tips for a Successful Taste-Off

  1. Embrace the Mardi Gras Spirit: This is your perfect excuse to use all those Mardi Gras decorations you’ve been collecting! Transform your space with a splash of purple, gold, and green. Hang up those masks and beads, and float in some balloons to really bring the Mardi Gras vibe to life. It’s all about creating a joyful and vibrant atmosphere.
  2. Keep the Mood Light and Joyful: The heart of this event is about having a great time with friends and family, sharing laughs over slices of King Cake. So, when it comes to judging, keep it playful and light-hearted. This isn’t a serious competition – it’s a celebration of good company and great cake!
  3. Capture the Joyful Moments: Amidst the fun, don’t forget to snap some pictures. Capture the beautifully decorated cakes, your guests’ happy faces, and all those special moments. These photos will be cherished reminders of a delightful Mardi Gras gathering.

With these tips, you’re all set for a memorable King Cake Taste-Off that’s full of Mardi Gras cheer, shared smiles, and a whole lot of delicious cake tasting!

So there you have it Lafayette! With these tips and a sprinkle of Mardi Gras magic, your King Cake Taste-Off is sure to be a hit. Share in the joy of discovering new flavors, laugh over your preferences, and most importantly, enjoy the warmth of good company.

Let the good times roll, and happy tasting!



Rochelle Campbell
Rochelle was born and raised in Lafayette, LA. She is a passionate writer and new mom, navigating the joys and challenges of motherhood. Married to her high school sweetheart, she cherishes the journey they've shared together in Acadiana. With an unwavering belief in the power of community, she is passionate about building connections and uplifting those around her. Rochelle believes that together, through sharing a smile, lending a helping hand, or offering a listening ear, we can create a world filled with love and positivity.